He Thought He Was Doing the Right Thing By Paying Child Support, But a DNA Test Revealed a Decade of Deception.

When the Original Poster (OP) believed he had fathered a child, he dutifully signed away paternity rights and began paying child support. However, after over a decade and $50,000 later, a shocking revelation about the mother’s multiple partners at the time emerges. As he grapples with feelings of betrayal and seeks legal recourse, questions of ethics, responsibility, and justice come to the forefront.

Unexpected News

pregnant couple fight chameleons eye shutterstockPin
image credit: chameleons-eye/shutterstock

OP has a short-lived relationship with a woman, which results in a pregnancy. At first, he thought they might start a committed relationship together, but their differences made it evident that this was not in the cards.

Signing Papers

male lawyer reading paperwork writing will minerva studio shutterstockPin
image credit: minerva-studio/shutterstock

Recognizing his perceived mistake, OP quickly signs away paternity rights but acknowledges the child was his at the hospital the day after the baby was born. Without hesitation, he agrees to pay child support.

A Hefty Price

guy money cash rain ground picture shutterstockPin
image credit: ground-picture/shutterstock

Over 12 long years, OP pays a staggering $50,000 in child support. He works hard, seeing a chunk of his wages siphoned off each time. His commitment remains unyielding, believing the money is for his child.

Dark Secrets Surface

Young handsome male afraid and shocked with surprise expression fear and shock face kraken images shutterstockPin
image credit: kraken images/shutterstock

OP uncovers shocking information. The woman he had dated was also seeing six other men around the same time. He realizes he was chosen as the “father” because of his financial stability and ability to contribute to child support.

Admission of Fault

young male confused unsure huh Asier Romero shutterstockPin
image credit: Asier Romero/shutterstock

OP acknowledges that he never got a DNA test at the start. The weight of this decision makes him feel like a fool in hindsight. Years later, OP finally gets the test. The results are clear and undeniable – the child is not his.

A Legal Battle Begins

senior judge holding book in courtroom legal lawyer sirtravelalot shutterstockPin
image credit: sirtravelalot/shutterstock

OP decides to sue the woman for the years of deceptive child support payments for a child that was not his. He feels wronged and gullible and wants retribution from the woman who played him like a fool. The legal papers are filed.

Accusations Fly

Emotional annoyed stressed couple fighting loud with each other fizkes shutterstockPin
image credit: fizkes/shutterstock

The woman is livid, citing her difficult financial situation and OP’s comparative wealth. In her eyes, his pursuit is simply mean. She has no other family members to help support her and her child.

Harsh Words Exchanged

couple fighting talking kaspars grinvalds shutterstockPin
image credit: kaspars-grinvalds/shutterstock

OP responds with a cold fury, telling her that her financial troubles are her own fault, a result of a lifetime of terrible choices. He wants his money back, no matter what. He will not give her one more penny to fund her bad decisions.

Garnished Wages

frustrated worried brunette man with beard no money empty pockets khosro shutterstockPin
image credit: khosro/shutterstock

OP reminisces about the financial strain. His wages were forcefully reduced to pay for a child that wasn’t even his. The sense of injustice and humiliation festers and grows, affecting all aspects of his life.

Suspicious Spending

young women shopping stores RossHelen shutterstockPin
image credit: RossHelen/shutterstock

OP suspects where the child support money went. Instead of the child’s welfare, he believes she spent it on nights out and pyramid schemes that he knows she’s been involved in. His trust is shattered.

A World Divided

angry group family arguing people antonio guillem shutterstockPin
image credit: antonio-guillem/shutterstock

Many come to the woman’s defense, suggesting she might have made an honest mistake. Others stand with OP. The court of public opinion is split. However, OP is resolute in his belief, arguing she had a duty to identify the birth father.

Financial Tensions

Man budgeting shutterstock MSNPin
image credit: shutterstock

Details of their financial disparities become public. While OP earns a comfortable $110,000 a year as a computer programmer, the woman makes just $35,000 as a daycare worker. The stakes of the lawsuit are high.

No Turning Back

stylish confident standing young male touch his beard roman samborskyi shutterstockPin
image credit: roman samborskyi/shutterstock

OP is determined. He has set his sights on retrieving the money, regardless of the fallout. His resolve remains unwavering. Some see OP as justified; others see him as vengeful. The ethical dilemmas are profound.

The Weight of a Mistake

guy hands on face male worried stressed grief guilt sad depressed troubled yakobchuk viacheslav shutterstockPin
image credit: yakobchuk-viacheslav/shutterstock

OP grapples with the repercussions of not getting a DNA test linger. Had he required it before signing the papers in the hospital, this entire saga might have been avoided. The lawsuit looms, and both sides brace for what’s to come.

Was The Man’s Behavior Appropriate?

pretty young woman shrug shoulders looks uncertain and glasses confused doubts huhPin
image credit: cast-of-thousands/shutterstock

OP posted his story online for feedback and perspective from the internet community. The readers in the forum had a lot of mixed views on the matter.

Forum Responds

happy young woman holding mobile phone social media looking up dean drobot shutterstockPin
image credit: dean-drobot/shutterstock

One reader said, “I’d talk to a lawyer ASAP. In the US, people can still be obligated to pay child support for a kid proven not to be theirs because they accepted the responsibility in the past.

Another Commenter Thinks 

mature business male using laptop computer working online sitting office social media aruta images shutterstockPin
image credit: aruta-images/shutterstock

Another responder wrote, “You should know even with proof that you aren’t the father, that doesn’t necessarily mean you are entitled to your money back. Honestly, you still might even have to pay child support.

A Third View on The Story

irritated male reads text message on smart phone remind him about bills needs to pay debts phone social media cast of thousands shutterstockPin
image credit: cast-of-thousands/shutterstock

A different person stated, “You’re doing this to be vindictive. You don’t need the money, and there’s no feasible way that she will be able to pay you back. You’re just going to make her spend more money on legal fees that may have gone towards the kid.

A Final Perspective on the Matter

surprised young adult bearded man standing using phone social media khosro shutterstockPin
image credit: khosro/shutterstock

Another reader commented, “OP is in the US, which means after 12 years, regardless of any paternity test that would occur, he is and basically always will be the father, and he would still be on the hook for child support. After a certain point, the law doesn’t care who the biological father is.

Peter Barlowe
+ posts

Peter focuses on lifestyle, travel, and trending news stories. Peter has written for several online publication and loves providing entertaining content. He is passionate about fashion, traveling, and social media.

Photo of author
About the author
Peter Barlowe